Alien vs Aliens vs My Childhood

Inspired by the fan-boy raving over at Condemned Movies and in anticipation of the June release of Ridley Scott’s prequel/not-a-prequel hybrid Prometheus, I decided to take a stroll down memory lane and revisit Scott’s iconic Alien and Cameron’s raucous Aliens.

What kind of damned robot are you?

I have such fond childhood memories of Scott’s Alien.  Even though I first watched it at a very young age (I think it must have been around the time of Aliens‘ release so I would’ve been about seven), it’s not memories of the film scaring me that I remember most, but memories instead of my parents telling stories of how it scared them when it came to theaters in 1979, also the year of my arrival into the world.  There was pent-up giddy kid-wild anticipation in the Schleicher household as our parents regaled tales of the shock and horror and the downright badass spookiness of Alien – a film that took old-school monster-movie horror and melded it with a new wave of gritty futurism.  It was both a throw-back film and pop-avant-garde.  And I remember feeling truly special when my parents finally let us watch it.  The initial shock of the chest-bursting scene lasts with me to this day as well as fractured fairy-tale memories of a an android that bled milk, an acid-filled face-hugging bug, a pretty girl in her underwear, and a kitty that must be rescued!

Watching it as an adult now, the psychosexual overtones are certainly not subtle – but such subtext was never meant to hide in the best of horror films.  Apart from the fantastic industrial-futuristic-gothic-grunge production design, the nightmare inducing creature models, and the 2001-like special effects that hold up to this day…what amazes and entertains me now is how steadfastly Scott adhered to the tropes of horror genre.  He used the monster on the ship like the mad killer of a slasher film with it slowly growing more unstoppable as it stalked and killed the crew one-by-one only to be one-upped by the lone surviving female.  In the form of Sigourney Weaver, this archetype took on a new tough exterior, but just when we thought all was well and done, Scott took us to that all-too familiar place…where a pretty young thing is getting undressed thinking she is safe and about to go into a literal deep sleep…only to have that damn monster show up right at her bedside for one last thrill.

Alien is a rock-solid genre mixing film filled with delectable pacing and old-fashioned suspense combined with new-age effects and gore.  It defined a generation of sci-fi films, but I’ll always hold fast that the movie it makes the best double-feature with is another classic of the era that has withheld the test of time, Halloween.

…and then what kind of damned robot are YOU?

And then came Aliens.  Oh, the cursing, the Marines, the action, the aliens, the DUN DUN…DUN DUN DUN…pounding of James Horner’s score…it was everything a little boy could want in a movie.  When Sigourney Weaver’s Ripley became the adoptive mother of little Newt and then went head to head with the Alien Queen, it was an epic battle of two bad-ass muthas!

The initial shock of the discovery of the nest scene lasts with me to this day as well as fractured fairy-tale memories of a an android named Bishop’s redemption, a macho-female marine’s last stand in an air shaft, a weasely pre-sitcom Paul Reiser receiving his just desserts, and a little girl who must be rescued!

This was the prototypical James Cameron movie – loud, locked and loaded whereas Scott’s original was creeping and gothic.  While the creature models still rank amongst the best in film history and the special effects were top-notch for their time, there’s a decidedly ’80’s set and sound design that make this sequel ironically more dated than the original.  There’s also the genesis of that Cameron heart (cheese) that would run amuck in his later films and turn him into the grandest sentimentalist next to Steven Spielberg.  But, dude…he still delivers the goods here and broke the mold on what sequels could achieve under new vision.

Cameron’s film was followed much later by two misguided sequels (the first of which is only notable for launching the career of David Fincher) and a god-awful series of comedies detailing the romance between Alien and Predator which seemed to exist for the sole purpose of tarnishing the legacy of Scott’s original.

Well, good ol’ Ridley apparently wanted to the set the record straight.  Next month marks the arrival of Prometheus.  Can Scott’s career of 30+ years come full circle?  Can this film bring back that wide-eyed kid-wild excitement by melding something old with something new?  Can that fear and awe live inside a mythos that has become this expansive?  Is this damn thing even really a prequel to Alien?  We shall see…we shall see…and hopefully once again in space, we shall collectively scream.

The trailer below I feel has set a new high point in teaser-dom.

Written by David H. Schleicher



  1. Nice writeup Dave. I too have my own memories of Alien/Aliens — the gooey fluids, the gore, the guts and the glory. It definitely was one of the best horror/sci-fi film I ever watched back then. So, I too am dying to watch Prometheus, which fortunately releases simultaneously in India on June 8th… YEAHH! And if the first-look is anything to go by it definitely looks more of a mind-game than it’s predecessors. Keeping my fingers crossed.

    Prakash – I’m stoked to hear we will be able to see Prometheus in theaters at the same time! Looking forward to swapping reviews and thoughts. –DHS

  2. Dave, I have to say that “Alien” is one of those movies that sits back in my unconscious and tries to play with my mind. Occasionally, I’ll descend a stairwell into someone’s basement, sweeping my flashlight back and forth in the darkness, and think “Ah shit, THIS is the time when an Alien is going to jump out at me”. Let’s not forget that all the jumps and visuals that were innovated in that movie are now CLICHE’.
    Additionally, “Blade Runner” is still one of those great movies that causes me to question my own existence. Am I really human? Of course, the movie varies greatly from Dick’s “Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?” but it only differs to create its own vision. Also, “Blade Runner” has some fantastic acting. Can you honestly say that you don’t feel deep compassion for Rutger Hauer as Roy Batty when he dies? I can’t.
    Based on just these two examples, I can almost guarantee two things from “Prometheus”. One, Scott will pull fantastic acting out of everyone in the ensemble. We will care deeply for each person and will feel genuine loss when they die. Two, we will get the BEJESUS scared out of us. It comes out June 1st, I’ll make sure I plan ahead since I won’t be sleeping for awhile after seeing it.

    Boz – I’m already in love with Charlize Theron screaming “TAKE US HOME!” in the trailer. Though, let’s be honest…I’ve always been in love with Charlize Theron. –DHS

  3. From my insatiable need to know about Prometheus, I’ve figured out that it’s inspired more by Aliens than Alien. The writers aren’t very accomplished in ways that impress me: a TV guy (Lost) and that Russian sci-fi movie about electric aliens that tanked last year. Freudian subtexts seem to be stripped from it just like the AVP movies, and a sort of Company Fucks Up plot is in the works again. Not sure that Ridley has the wherewithal to hit a home run with that, but it at least instantly looks better than Alien 4 and AVP 1 & 2, so I will be there opening night regardless.

    Yo, dude, way to rain on your own parade! I’ll be the first to admit most good directors will typically “screw the pooch” when trying to go home (yikes – Spielberg and that last Indiana Jones film – what a train wreck!) but if anyone can pull off something like this it’s Ridley Scott. This looks more inspired by 2001 than anything – but I reserve all judgement good or bad until seeing the finished product. –DHS

    • Good grief, Indy 4 was horrible. Predictably, Cate was wonderful in it though. I think South Park had it right to say Lucas and Spielberg sexually assaulted poor Indy.

      And yeah, I’m not getting my hopes up after seeing the writers for Prometheus. But the good news is that it has some wonderful actors, especially Fassbender in the Ian Holm / Lance Henriksen role.

      And don’t forget my fave, Charlize. –DHS

  4. I didn’t see these movies until I was in college around 1993 or 1994. Someone (I don’t remember who) gave me a VHS box set of the three movies for Christmas. I wasn’t particularly thrilled because I didn’t love horror movies the way I do now, and I had no affection for sci-fi.

    But I put in the first tape and was riveted from the first shots. It struck me as being so brilliant that, even though I wasn’t a fan of the genre, I still loved the movie. When the tape ended I immediately put in Aliens and enjoyed that as well, though for completely different reasons. You do a good job of highlighting the atmosphere in Alien as opposed to the in-your-face action of Aliens.

    As a footnote, I did put in the third movie immediately after the second and was pissed off almost from the beginning. After the great ending to Aliens… Really? Everyone died except Ripley? And the movie was insufferable from then on.

    I am curious to see Prometheus, but I’m not expecting anything great. I hope I love it, but I have to be pragmatic about these things. It’ll probably be pretty bad.

    Jason – oh man, I was soooooo pissed off at Alien 3. For me – it MURDERED the first two films. Poor Fincher, what a way to start a directing career. What a travesty! –DHS

  5. […] Alien vs. Aliens vs. My Childhood Share this:TwitterFacebookPinterestLinkedInStumbleUponDiggRedditTumblrEmailLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was posted in Movie Reviews, Movies, Pop Culture and tagged Alien, Alien Mythology, Alien Series, Aliens, Charlize Theron, Guy Pearce, Idris Elba, Michael Fassbender, Noomi Rapace, Origin Stories, Prometheus, Ridley Scott, Sci-fi, Space Exploration, Weyland Corporation. […]

Provide your own Spin and tell us what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s