This War Has Put an End to Decent Things

Hope and Glory Title Photo

For many, childhood is a war: a battle of wills with adults, a rage against growing up, a fight against awakening into the violent world of adulthood.  It’s not surprising then that many of the greatest films about childhood and coming of age take place against the backdrop of actual wars.  Three of the top five films in my list of the 41 greatest films about childhood involve war and how children and adults learn to deal with it in different ways.  Many of the films on this list (including the film at number one) are no doubt sentimental favorites (arguments could easily be made there are grander artistic achievements further down the list).  It should come as no surprise that these sentimental favorites were first seen in childhood and that many of the films come from directors delving deep into the wellspring of nostalgia and semi-autobiography; those indelible moments from our shared childhoods crystalized onto the silver screen.

I was about the same age as the protagonist, Billy Rohan, when I first saw John Boorman’s Hope and Glory.  I loved every bit of it, and even at that young age I knew there was something unique about its point of view.  It painted war as how I imagined I (as a child at the time) would’ve reacted to it: a blast of excitement in an otherwise mundane suburban life previously populated by games and make-believe.  Here my soldiers and toys had come to life, dirigibles suspended in air over my streets, German bombers flying overhead, danger and adventure lying in the rubble of my neighbors demolished homes.  The juxtaposition of adult horrors and children’s games (a juxtaposition dealt with far more seriously and catastrophically in films like Forbidden Games and Come and See) resulted in a picture of scrappy, working-glass survivors striving for a sense of normalcy and return to innocence in a world gone stark raving mad. 

Watching Hope and Glory as child I was enthralled by the child’s eye view of World War II and the German blitzkrieg of London.  I’ve watched it many times over the years and its shades and shadows of the human condition under stress undulate in both nuanced and histrionic ways as I grew into adulthood.  Watching it now in my thirties I’m struck by the over-the-top nature of the adults in the film (who often responded to the stress of war with hysterics, gallows humor, irrational actions or drunken wistfulness).  I hadn’t noticed in my early viewings the quick crumbling of the marriage of Molly and Mac, or the quietly tragic unrequited love between Mac and Grace.  The tween-age Pauline has also emerged in later viewings as one of the most fascinating marginalized characters, displaying on the sidelines the stages of grief in both tempestuous and innocent ways after her mother is obliterated along with her house, a young girl forced to grow up too fast, clinging to that last thread of childhood.

It’s also funny that this sentimental favorite, like my own memories of childhood, exists somewhere in that strange in-between world of holding up well and not holding up well at all.  My recollections of the film are often more inspiring than sitting through it for the twentieth time.  Yet still, I will never forget it…like Billy says in the film’s classic closing moments, “In all my life nothing ever quite matched the perfect joy of that moment. My school lay in ruins, the river beckoned with the promise of stolen days.”

I’ve compiled this list as my official ballot entry for Wonders in the Dark upcoming Top Childhood Films Countdown, sure to be another epic film-lovers extravaganza of fantastic essays from the premier independently run film blog and written by some of the most esteemed film bloggers I know.  Like most participating, I went with a loose definition: any film where a child or teenager, or someone’s childhood, plays a major role in the action on-screen.

Without further adieu, I present to you The Spin’s Top 41 Films about Childhood:

Hope and Glory #1

1. Hope and Glory (UK, 1987, d. John Boorman)

Fanny and Alexander #2

2. Fanny & Alexander (Sweden, 1982, d. Ingmar Bergman)

Au Revoir Les Enfants #3

3. Au Revoir Les Enfants (France, 1987, d. Louis Malle)

Forbidden Games #4

4. Forbidden Games (France, 1952, d. Rene Clement)

Bicyle Thieves #5

5. Bicycle Thieves (Italy, 1948, d. Vittorio de Sica)

6. The Night of the Hunter (USA, 1955, d. Charles Laughton)

7. To Kill a Mockingbird (USA, 1962, d. Robert Mulligan)

8. The Tree of Life (USA, 2011, d. Terrence Malick)

9. Cinema Paradiso (Italy, 1988, d. Giuseppe Tornatore)

10. How Green Was My Valley (USA, 1941, d. John Ford)

11. Oliver Twist (UK, 1948, d. David Lean)

12. Ivan’s Childhood (Russia, 1962, d. Andrei Tarkovsky)

13. The White Ribbon (Germany, 2009 d. Michael Haneke)

14. Come and See (Russia, 1985, d. Elem Klimov)

15. Yi Yi (Japan, 2000, Edward Yang)

16. The Kid with a Bike (Belgium, 2011, d. The Dardennes)

The River #17

17. The River (France, 1951, d. Jean Renoir)

18. The Innocents (UK, 1961, d. Jack Clayton)

19. The Spirit of the Beehive (Spain, 1973, d. Victor Erice)

20. The Mirror (Russia, 1975, d. Andrei Tarkovsky)

21. The Tree of Wooden Clogs (Italy, 1978, d. Ermanno Olmi)

The Long Day Closes #22

22. The Long Day Closes (UK, 1992, d. Terence Davies)

23. The Thief (Russia, 1997, d. Pavel Chukhray)

24. The Adventures of Baron Munchausen (UK, 1988, d. Terry Gilliam)

25. Mud (USA, 2012, d. Jeff Nichols)

26. Paper Moon (USA, 1973, d. Peter Bogdanovich)

27. Small Change (France, 1976, d. Francois Truffaut)

28. American Graffiti (USA, 1973, d. George Lucas)

29. Dazed and Confused (USA, 1993, d. Richard Linklater)

30. Heathers (USA, 1988, d. Michael Lehmann)

31. River’s Edge (USA, 1986, d. Tim Hunter)

32. Stand By Me (USA, 1986, d. Rob Reiner)

33. Boyhood (USA, 2014, d. Richard Linklater)

34. The 400 Blows (France, 1959, d. Francois Truffaut)

35. A Christmas Story (USA, 1983, d. Bob Clark)

36. Toto the Hero (France, 1991, d. Jaco Van Dormeal)

37. My Life as a Dog (Sweden, 1985, d. Lasse Hallstrom)

38. Faces of Children (France, 1925, d. Jacques Feyder)

39. Heavenly Creatures (New Zealand, 1995, d. Peter Jackson)

Eve's Bayou #40

40. Eve’s Bayou (USA, 1997, d. Kasi Lemmons)

41. Oliver! (UK, 1968, d. Carol Reed)

Written by David H. Schleicher

Click here to follow the countdown at Wonders in the Dark.

Click here to see John Greco’s fabulous list at Twenty Four Frames.

What are your favorite films about childhood?  Share your spin with a comment!

Advertisements

10 comments on “This War Has Put an End to Decent Things

  1. John Greco says:

    David, this is a fabulous list. I thought your short essay on HOPE AND GLORY and its significance to you was deeply moving. I like that you included MUD in your list. That was one I did not even think of. THE INNOCENTS was another that I could have easily included in my list had I thought of it.

    • I think MUD slips the mind so easily because it was so recent. I find when people compile these lists they take great effort to stretch far back into the vaults for those “classics” – we sometimes overlook the new ones that haven’t had time yet to age like fine wine.

  2. Marshall says:

    Excellent list! What qualifies as “childhood,” though? If it includes older teens, I would definitely say FISH TANK ranks towards the top of mine. It’s the most artful invocation of the listlessness and confusion of being an adolescent that I’ve ever seen.

    • Marshall – you know what, you’re right. It wouldn’t be near the top for me, but FISH TANK does deserve a spot on the list. The original ask for this countdown was to rank 60 films…which I found too daunting as once you get beyond a Top Ten, the rankings often become catch-all’s and arbitrary. Had I tried to do 60, FISH TANK probably would’ve eventually sprung to mind.

      • Marshall says:

        Yeah, big long lists are tough. A friend of mine recently asked for a 100 movies to watch before you die list, and it’s hard to make that with quality control.

  3. ccyager says:

    Love this list, David. Really made me think. For me, “To Kill a Mockingbird” would be my first choice followed by “Tiger Bay” (1959), “The Lord of the Flies,” and “Fanny and Alexander” — off the top of my head. All these movies had a profound effect on me, some in childhood, some in my 20’s and looking back to my childhood. I’m not sure I’d want to go any further, but I still like your list and pleased to see so many foreign films on it. Cinda

  4. Arti says:

    David,

    I don’t see Empire of the Sun on your list. This is one of the most haunting movies on childhood and war I’ve ever seen.

  5. […] two beloved films, The Tree of Life and The Night of the Hunter.  Readers might recall I published the ballot I submitted to WitD not too long ago.  And while my personal rankings and choices might differ from the final […]

Provide your own Spin and tell us what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s