It Ain’t Over ’til the Last Soprano Sings

The fat lady has sung. 

Sunday, June 10th marks the final episode of one of the most celebrated shows in history, HBO’s The Sopranos.

The Sopranos

Hard to believe, it’s been close to a decade and 6 1/2 seasons since The Sopranos debuted and made HBO a perennial Emmy contender and the prime spot for appointment television.  Having been in college when it began, I didn’t settle in as a regular viewer until Season Three.  By this point, the show was already getting backlash from critics and viewers, but this is the season where I fell in love with the show.  I eventually caught the first two seasons on reruns, and they were truly some of the most expertly crafted, wonderfully scripted, and thoughtfully acted 24 hours of television ever produced.   As the show has progressed, it’s had its fair share of stale and boring episodes, but it’s always been reliable for a few good surprises (I still get emotional over Adriana’s demise) and tour-de-force acting (especially from Edie Falco as Tony’s long suffering wife, Carmella Soprano).

This last half season has been a thrilling throwback to the original conceit with mob kingpin Tony Soprano (James Gandolfini) breaking the code by being on the couch with Dr. Jennifer Melfi (Lorraine Bracco) to help deal with his depression, family and “family” problems, and huge mother issues.  There was the early (though expected) shock of Tony doing a self-inflicted whacking of his nephew Christopher.  Then we had Anthony Jr. trying to commit suicide.  Finally, there was Tony putting out a hit on Phil Leotardo only to have it hilariously and horribly botched.  

The next to last episode was simply amazing, delivering exactly what viewers wanted with Melfi cutting Tony off fearing he will always be a sociopath beyond help, and Tony’s “family” coming undone when their New Jersey outfit is put on the chopping block by Phil’s New York crew.  In Sunday’s final episode…will Tony, now in hiding after Silvio was put in a coma and Bobby murdered, finally get what’s been coming to him and get whacked by Phil Leotardo, or will he prove too cunning and get Phil first?  One thing is for sure, no matter who lives and dies, this Sunday will be a sad day for the diehard fans who have gone through all the ups and downs over the years and consider The Sopranos part of their extended family.

Sunday, June 10th 2007.  9pm EST.  The end of an era for HBO.  Fughedaboutit.

 ___________________________________________________________________________

The following was added after three full hours of “digesting” that final scene…*potential spoiler for those who have yet to watch…proceed with caution.

Yes, there was that darkly humorous scene of Phil Leotardo finally getting whacked-in front of his wife and grandbabies no less!  I loved the shot of the on-looker throwing up when the SVU crushed Phil’s skull-oh, and the sound effects!  Bravo!

Other than that, the final episode was a huge letdown after a fantastic next-to-last episode.  David Chase closed with a scene of Tony’s family gathering in a diner that in and of itself was obnoxiously banal, but in the context of the show was riddled with suspense.  It was a nicely done magic trick, making something out of nothing, and then cutting to a black screen and dead silence just when you thought something horrible was going to happen.  It’s a fine way to cheat a loyal audience, left thoughtful for a moment in their befuddlement, and then slowly recognizing what a shyster Chase was in those final moments.

My final two interpretations:

1.  It’s a cynical con job leaving the possibility of a movie wide open.

2.  It’s a massive cop out parading as high art.  Fools will argue Chase wanted to leave everything to the audience’s imagination that could run wild with theories on what happened when the screen faded to black.  Some will say Tony was whacked, and it went to black, just as he had talked about earlier in the season with Bobby.  Some will even go as far to say the audience was whacked, and we were what went to black.  I say David Chase had no idea how to satisfy an audience.  We watched the show for the high drama, not to use or imaginations and choose our own adventures.  That big scene could’ve been so wonderful…Carmela leaving Tony…Tony getting dragged away by the Feds for good…Tony getting whacked.   There were so many viable options that could’ve all satisfied fans in one way or the other.  Instead…a blank screen.  David Chase, you should be ashamed.

Written by David H. Schleicher

Advertisements

7 comments on “It Ain’t Over ’til the Last Soprano Sings

  1. Angiebo says:

    I just wished I could afford HBO and not have to wait until it is available with Netflix/A&E. But telling me how it ends is killing me! I’m always closing my eyes/ears and thus seeing it outright just isn’t right.

  2. walnotes says:

    Do you know of a video sharing site where someone has posted the final episode? I can’t find one. Someone’s gotta do it. I tried to watch at a few different bars but no one carries HBO.
    (http://walnotes.wordpress.com)

  3. Nancy says:

    Oh, I was PISSED. Very much so.
    I agree with the high art concept, especially given the fact that the title is “Made in America” and there they were enjoying a pleasant meal in a diner, surrounded by other families and happy people, listening to a classic American song. Maybe Chase was trying to do the reverse of what Francis Ford Coppola wanted to achieve with The Godfather. Instead of the typical America values being money, greed, and power, the last scene presents a picture of family unity despite any obstacles. Throughout there seemed to be allusions to the values of simplicity, family, and faith despite the unknown.
    The episode was done nicely–people get whacked, life goes on, etc., but it was nothing to write home about. I’ve watched episodes sporadically over the years, and whenever I catch a good episode I drag someone into watching the next–only to have them look at me in total disbelief, with me shaking my head and shrugging my shoulders, when it is a boring one,.
    Most of the scenes did play out nicely, lots of tension. Every time someone got into a car I thought it would explode. And what was the thing with the cat? Don’t set up a piece like that and not use it. Seriously. And the guy going to the bathroom in the diner? I thought for sure there was a gun strapped to the back of one of the toilets.
    At least it defied expectations of Tony dying. I was hoping they wouldn’t kill him or the members of his family. But as a final episode it could have been better. Much better.

    Nancy, I agree with you assessment. I’m still fuming…such a cop out. I don’t expect everything to be tied up, and the last thing I would want is closure…but leave us with something dramatic…something climactic. Phil’s head getting crushed by the SUV just didn’t cut it. And an ambiguous fade to black shows a complete lack of respect for the loyal fans on Chase’s part. –DHS

  4. Horse Apples says:

    I think you hit the nail on the head . I read about all those hailing David Chase as genius, when we all need to just face the fact. ACTING carried much of this show, and after Season 2, the writing slowly fell apart except for a few classic “mob” and “family” moments. But this was a cop out by David Chase. He cheated the viewers. He succeeded in creating a controversial ending, but that is part of the problem. There was no true ending. For a season finale, this would have been amazing. Talked about all year. But for SERIES finale, this is just lazy writing. This in my mind is one of the greatest, but overrated shows in TV history.

  5. Anonymous says:

    I do not agree. I felt that the two hoods in the restaurant in the final scene were Tony’s guys and showed that he took a step up into the NY area by taking out Phil and now he was going to make sure he was always guarded. Pure genius!
    Johnnie

  6. Lita says:

    After hearing all the hype and the disappointment as America saw the last ep a few months before NZ, I wasn’t as disappointed as I thought I would be. I totally felt the juxtaposition of tension (are the strangers killers) and everyday routine (waiting) in the last scene. The only fault I consider was the fakeness of the last Soprano family supper. I don’t recall them ever meeting for dinner like that before, it felt contrived somehow. Maybe I was prepared for the dead ending after hearing about it around the world first, I can’t really imagine how else it could’ve been done.

    I miss Tony now he’s gone, I cling to re-runs like an addict.

    Lita, good point! The whole family getting together at a diner like that was very contrived, especially after all they had been through. –DHS

  7. Anonymous says:

    I thought the last episode was great. David Chase let the viewer decide on the ending. Whatever you thought happened after fading to black is your own memory of the series. Best TV show ever.

Provide your own Spin and tell us what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s