The Winter of our Discontent

Okay, so 2009 has been a fairly solid and entertaining year for films thus far…but is it just me, or is there very little to get excited about in these last few months?  Last year, 5 of the 10 films to make the top ten list for my annual Davies Awards were released in the final two months of the year.  This year, there’s nothing that has me as excited as I was last year about Doubt, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Frost/Nixon or Revolutionary Road — films with pedigree, class, all-star casts, interesting stories — you know, the type of stuff Oscar loves.  It seems every piece of Oscar bait was withheld until those last few weeks of December last year (let us not forget The Wrestler as well).    Hollywood spoiled us.  Yet…maybe there will be more of an element of surprise this year, and there will be that little film that comes out of nowhere  — and I’m sorry, folks, but you can’t tell me that films like last year’s Slumdog Millionaire or this year’s Precious came out of nowhere with all that highly manipulative prepackaged positive buzz and carefully platformed release schedules designed to maximize profit.  2009 has been full of surprises — who would’ve thought that Inglourious Basterds or District 9 would’ve been so good — so I’m holding out hope…and here’s my buzz on what films might become those diamonds in the rough.

Lest I remain discontent…here are my most anticipated films for the Winter Season 2009/2010.


The White Ribbon (Michael Haneke, limited release Christmas Day 2009).  This Palm D’Or winner from Cannes appears to be both Haneke’s most artistic and accessible film to date.  This seems a shoe-in for a Best Foreign Language Film nomination, though it could strike an even deeper cord, and seems destined to do for the cold, austere Haneke (Funny Games, The Time of the Wolf, Cache) what The Sweet Hereafter did for Atom Egoyan.  Thematically, there appears to be shades of religious films like Doubt or Silent Light or any from Dreyer’s canon, while the intimate, small-town story is anchored in a pre-WWI Germany ripe for, you know, all that stuff historians and artists and socio-political theorists and psychologists love to delve into when trying to uncover, “What happened to make the people do THAT?”  It all sounds well and good, but what really clinched this for me was the preview.  I haven’t responded to a preview like this since the original trailer for There Will Be Blood — a completely different type of film on the surface, but like this White Ribbon, appears to be a measured departure from the director’s previous works, and just oozes “THIS IS ART!”  It chilled me to the bone.  Here’s hoping the film does the same.


Up in the Air (Jason Reitman, NYC and LA December 4th 2009, wide release Christmas Day).  Can director Jason Reitman duplicate the success of Juno?  Will George Clooney finally score a massive commercial hit outside of those awful Oceans “Insert Number Here” films?  Will Vera Farmiga (unsung for her roles in The Departed and The Boy in the Striped Pajamas) finally score that first Oscar nomination?  Already, this film, which bares a striking resemblance to the detached type-A male personality Reitman previously put cleverly on display in Thank You for Smoking, has some critics gushing, “Why don’t they make more movies like this?”  In other words, it looks to be targeted at adults, smartly written, well directed, well cast and will tackle relationships in a mature, thoughtful way.  The preview is slick and well done, and I’m just hoping is makes enough money so at the very least those whining critics will shut their traps.  I jest…seriously, look at this preview!  Why don’t they make more movies like this?  This thing is a shoe-in Jerry Maguire-style Oscar-bound piece of entertainment.


The Road (John Hillcoat, November 25th, 2009)  I have to admit, I’ve been running hot and cold on this one.  I thought Cormac McCarthy’s book was good but a bit overrated…though its stark minimalism made it ripe for a pulsating and thrilling film adaptation.  I got onboard when John Hillcoat was announced as the director — I loved his grim Aussie Western The Proposition.  But when the first images started floating around, I thought, man, they got it all wrong.  Then there was a delayed release date — this was originally slated for November 2008.  Then there was the first Hollywoodized preview, which made it look like a terribly rote post apocalyptic action film.  But now the reviews are coming out, and though they are mixed, the ones that lean positive are positively rapturous…and the word is, Hillcoat got his cut out there and McCarthy’s vision is in tact.  The original trailer was a studio hack-job but this one is a little better:


Edge of Darkness (Martin Campell, January 29th 2010) Mel Gibson goes bat-shit insane in an attempt to uncover who murdered his daughter.  Looking to tap into the same audience that flocked to 2009’s Taken, Martin Campell (The Mask of Zorro, Casino Royale) directs this from a script by William Monahan (The Departed).  Unlike the total suck-fest that was Taken, this flick actually looks good…and we haven’t seen Gibson kick-ass in front of the camera in a long time.  Check it out:


Shutter Island (Marin Scosese, February 19th 2010) Some of you might remember this was on my Summer/Fall Preview post earlier in the year, but after bombarding us with the schlocky trailer, the studio pulled the film at the last minute and changed the release date from October 2009 to February 2010.  I’ve never hid the fact that Scorsese is one of my all-time favorite directors, and thanks to previous and superb film adaptations of some of his other novels (Mystic River, Gone Baby Gone) Dennis Lehane is one my favorite writers whom I’ve never actually read.  This looks to me like Scorsese doing his own Hitchcock riff, and hell, even if this is no better than Cape Fear (which is still a pretty entertaining flick), then that will still be a most welcome relief in the middle of February, which is typically the worst time of the year for quality films.  Here’s the new preview:


Other films of potential interest:

November 2009:

  • Fantastic Mr. Fox (already in limited release, wide on Turkey Day) Meryl Streep!  George Clooney!  Animated!  In Stop-Motion!  By Wes Anderson!
  • Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans (already in limited release).  Shoe-eating German Werner Herzog directing American lunatic Nicolas Cage in an update…homage…remake…sequel…WTF? of that amoral Harvey Keitel film?  Sign me up!
  • Broken Embraces (already in limited release).  Pedro Almodovar directing Penelope Cruz…again.  Ay yi yi.

December 2009:

  • Brothers (December 4th).  An inexplicable remake of a quiet, intimate Dutch film that is currently being advertised as a melodramatic thriller.  Natalie Portman looks good at least.  Tobey Maguire promises to over-act.
  • Invictus (December 11th).  This should successfully reunite the Clint Eastwood “Commercial Hit” with the Clint Eastwood “Oscar Bait”.  This is my early bet for Best Picture.
  • The Lovely Bones (December 11th).  Peter Jackson directs the adaptation of the international best-selling novel.  Sounds good on paper, but am I the only one who thought the previews were hokey?
  • Avatar (December 18th).  This is only on the list because it looks so monumentally unfathomably terrible — like a video-game update of The Smurfs mixed with a monstrously cliched “star-crossed love story in a time of war” plotline.  I keep hearing that goofily slack-jawed “You’re not in Kansas anymore, you’re on Pandora” line from the previews over and over in my head.  What was Cameron thinking?  This will either be the season’s biggest bomb or biggest hit. 
  • The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus (Christmas Day).  The previews look like a mess, but this certainly has potential if Terry Gilliam gets the tone right…and there’s the Heath Ledger factor that should bring in the curious.

January 2010:

  • The Book of Eli (January 15th) Yet another post-apocalyptic opus with an obvious religious message.  This one stars Denzel Washington instead of Will Smith.  At least the Hughes Brothers (From Hell) deliver up some hellishly cool imagery in the previews.

February 2010:

  • The Crazies (February 26th).  The apocalypse.  Small town.  Zombies.  Or something.  Remake of the Romero flick.  This is only on the list because the preview was actually kinda good, though how many of these types of films do we need before the actual end of the world?

Written by David H. Schleicher


So what films are you most excited about this winter?  Leave a comment and be heard.


  1. Hi! D.H.Schleicher,
    I must admit that the film Shutter Island has caught my attention. I will return later in order to expound on what other films from 2009/2010 have caught my attention and why.

    Take care!
    DeeDee 😉

    DeeDee — Shutter Island certainly has a noirish look to it. –DHS

  2. I can’t wait for “Shutter Island.” I read the book over the summer and it was a trippy ride. I’m curious to see Scorsese’s take on it. I’m glad you mentioned his remake of “Cape Fear.” That doesn’t get nearly the amount of love that it deserves.

    And it may be just me, but does DiCaprio’s goatee seem out of context with the period? I don’t know how many people were sporting those back in the ’40s. Like I said, could be just me.

    I’m looking forward to “Sherlock Holmes.” I loved reading the stories when I was younger and, unlike other Holmes fans, I like the idea of updating him out of his usual trappings. I like the casting and, though I run hot and cold with Guy Ritchie, I think this has a shot at being incredibly fun. Ditto “Imaginarium” and “Avatar.”

    Hmmm…Chris, maybe now with the delayed release, I could actually read Shutter Island beforehand! Thanks for the great idea. I have to say, though, Guy Ritchie’s spin on Sherlock Holmes looks to be a travesty and so far removed from the source material as to be unrecognizable. –DHS

  3. Well David, I saw FANTASTIC MR. FOX last week, BAD LIETENANT last night, and BROKEN EMBRACES this afternoon before Sukurov’s THE SUN, and I must say that all three are rather essential. Herzog’s film is the best and most important, but the Russian film is also one of the best films of the year. BROKEN EMBRACES is somewhat convoluted but as always Almodovar’s characters and norish story are fascinating. It doesn’t have to be one of his best to work, and I would say it’s still essential.

    Of the others, I hanker for THE WHITE RIBBON most of all, will see THE ROAD on Wednesday night, and have also heard the serious talk about UP IN THE AIR, INVICTUS and THE LOVELY BONES.

    But no David it’s not you. I completely agree that last years and years before that were far more exciting year-end release-wise. I dare say we’ve had most of our great stuff already.

    Sam, I am glad to hear your thumbs up for all four! I had hoped the Herzog would be playing in Philly, but not yet…so I wait. I really can’t imagine anything in the next two months topping A Serious Man or The Hurt Locker…though wouldn’t mind being pleasantly surprised. –DHS

  4. I’ll agree — last year had a huge number of prestige films come out at the last minute and that just doesn’t look to be the case this year.

    I’m curious about UP IN THE AIR and just hope that it’s not too sappy. The preview does look great and it will be nice to have a (hopefully) intelligent date movie to take my wife to go see 🙂

    Troy, yes, I am hoping it turns out to be that rare “date flick” both men and women can enjoy and doesn’t pander to the lowest common denominator. –DHS

  5. Yes, David I quite agree 2009 has not been up to the standards of the previous few years. Like you, I am a big Scorsese fan and was looking forward to ‘Shutter Island’ this fall but alas, we have to wait. I read the novel, actually listened to the book on CD, some time ago. It is a very good read.

    One minor correction on Chris Tait’s comment. The book take place in the early 1950’s, not the 1940’s, I believe 1954 ,still, his comment about the goatee is valid. I doubt U.S, Marshall’s were wearing them in the early 50’s. Most likely only artists and other residents of areas like Greenwich Village were prominent in sporting goatees at the time.

    John, yes, the goatee does seem an odd choice. DiCaprio often makes odd choices…like the accent in Blood Diamond. –DHS

  6. Hi! D.H.Schleicher,
    Wow, I just watched every trailer that you posted…
    Shutter Island does look very noirish…most definitely, the one for me to watch.

    D.H.Schleicher said, “Mel Gibson goes bat-sh** insane in an attempt to uncover who murdered his daughter…”
    (Laughter!…You do not mince your word…do you?)

    The Road looks like a very interesting film too!
    This “whining critic” think that the film Up in the Air looks great too!

    It seems as if the film The White Ribbon is going to be the… “winner” when it comes to all the films that you posted here on your blog.

    Unfortunately, for me I will have to wait until the films are on DVDs or are on cable.

    Because I ‘am unable to sit in the theatre for prolonged period without experiencing major headaches…Therefore, my movie going days are behind me forever.

    Thanks, for sharing this post with your readers.
    Take care!
    DeeDee 😉

  7. D.H. Schleicher, I ‘am not sure if you celebrate Thanksgiving? 😕

    If so, I hope that you and your family have a very pleasant, warm, and reflective Thanksgiving too!

    Take care!
    DeeDee 😉

    DeeDee – Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday! Thank you. I wish the same for you and yours. –DHS

  8. Hi! D.H.Schleicher,
    I too just checked out the trailer for the film Sherlock Holmes (Over there on IMDB) and as far as I ‘am concerned that trailer looks great, but we shall see…
    …By the way, my mère introduced me to Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson’s films.

    Take care!
    DeeDee 😉 🙂

Provide your own Spin and tell us what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s